The Press Club

Note: The Press Club has now moved to the venue next door and has been revamped.  Read my updated review here 

Almost the last person I expected to bump into at The Press Club was George Calombaris.  I’m a little bit cynical about celebrity chefs especially if they have multiple restaurants and presumed Calombaris would not be spending his Saturday night working the pass at The Press Club.  But as I was waiting for my table (more on that later) it was Calombaris himself who tapped me on the back and said “Please tell me someone is looking after you”.  He really worked the room, chatting to all the diners and happily posing for photos with people as well as putting in time in the kitchen.

Sword fish at The Press Club

Calombaris’ presence wasn’t the only thing that impressed me at The Press Club.  The room itself is beautiful at night – all dark and sexy with the light and action focused on the open kitchen.  The food at The Press Club draws on Calombaris’ Greek background but offers a very contemporary take on the nation’s cuisine.  This is a Greek restaurant with no saganaki as a starter or lamb as a main. The dishes we tried had more in common with Calombaris’ cooking at his first restaurant Reserve than the robust Greek food The Press Club served when it first opened.

The sleek interior of The Press Club

To start MTV and I shared an entrée of lightly seared medallions of sword fish ($30.90) with sea weeds and vegetables along with a creamy ouzo flavoured mayonnaise.  The fish was only just done to a blush pink state proving to be a light and delicate starter.  Continuing on the seafood theme the John Dory ($49.90) was served crispy skinned with cubes of “jowl” which was like bacon and a scattering of pearl barley soaked in rich flavours.  It was the sort of dish that was studded with morsels which made picking through it like a treasure hunt.

John Dory at The Press Club

The wagyu steak ($60) was a flank of oyster blade, cooked to medium rare and served with mash and heirloom carrots.  While the steak was perfectly cooked it was a bit of a busy dish and the flavours were at times too crowded.    We also ordered a side of chips ($11) which were really superfluous as the serving sizes at The Press Club are generous.

Chips Press Club Style

To finish, the dessert menu is strong and in particular the passionfruit soufflé  ($21.90) was so light and ethereal that it was still rising when it arrived at our table.  Although I hadn’t mentioned when booking that our meal was in celebration of MTV’s birthday our clever waitress overheard us talking about his birthday and so had organised for the soufflé to have a happy birthday message.

Wagyu steak at The Press Club

Her initiative was a bit atypical of the service we received all night. While the guidance provided by the sommelier who talked us through the (lengthy) wine list before recommending an excellent bottle of wine was excellent other staff did not impress.  The wine in question was the Rusden ‘Full Circle’ Mataro ($88) which was medium bodied and fruity while not being too tannin heavy – delicious.

Passionfruit soufflé for MTV’s birthday

The thing that really irked me was that when we arrived for our 9pm booking and had to spend almost 10 minutes standing at the kitchen pass waiting for our table to be turned.  If a wait is required then at a restaurant of this quality I would expect there to be a bar area to wait in.   Unprompted, the maitre d’ presented me with a glass of sparkling wine (not asking me if I wanted one) which I presumed was to apologise for the wait.  The gesture was lovely and would have made up for any inconvenience but I was surprised to get home and find the drink had been included on my bill.

The food at The Press Club is clever and elaborate but at times over-wrought.  The place has a great buzz to it and makes the most of the George Calombaris celebrity factor but service was erratic, alternating from brilliant to non-existent.  For a special occasion I think there are better places in Melbourne.

View Gourmet Chick Melbourne in a larger map 

Details: The Press Club,  72 Flinders Street  Melbourne 3000 (Ph: 03 9677 9677) Lunch Mon – Sun: 12pm–3pm,  Dinner Mon-Sun: 6pm–10pm.
Damage: Over $300 for two with one bottle of wine.

The Press Club on Urbanspoon


  1. For a place like this, I would have expected the service to be one of the best things. Shame that it wasn’t.

    At least the waitress was thoughtful, and the food looks brilliant!

  2. Woah, I wouldn’t expect to see GC there either! He wasn’t there when I went years ago.
    Shame that the drink ended up on your bill… surely it shoulda been comped!

  3. Wow! Awesome not to just see George, but have him double check that you’re doing okay! I’ll admit to still not having been to Press Club, just because the prices give me a bit of a fright…the food does look lovely though, shame about the service…and what cheek to charge for the drink!

  4. The Food seems to be less experimental or edge pushing than before? Or it was just some individual dishes.. I do like going to Maha for their fried doughnuts though : )

  5. Shame the service and food wasn’t better! What a nice HB dessert though!!!

  6. Sophie – Yes it’s a shame it was not up to scratch

    Shellie – I totally was not expecting him but it did add a nice touch of celebrity to the evening.

    Ashley – He was really checking in on everyone all the time, and doing a better job of it than his staff. Yes pretty annoying about the drink.

    HK Epicurus – That could be because we didn’t order the degustation – with a 9pm booking I felt it was a bit late to survive multiple bookigns.

    Andi – Yes it was a great birthday dessert.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *