The Rickshaw: Not a review

DSC04760

This is not a review of Gertrude street’s latest restaurant, Rickshaw Dining.  I went to a media and blogger preview for the restaurant but bloggers are coming under fire at the moment for attending restaurant these sort of events and then writing “really enthusiastic write-ups about how fabulous the venue, the food, the drinks and the owners are (always, mind you, with a little disclaimer at the bottom about how the writer attended as a non-paying guest – their integrity is scrupulous).”  That was The Age’s chief reviewer, Larissa Dubecki.  Today, Guardian reviewer Jay Rayner tweeted “Arguing with an effing blogger who doesn’t think that taking a freebie in any way degrades the validity of their opinion”.   

Not a review of The Rickshaw
Chicken mince curry with that green papaya salad at The Rickshaw

Sorry Larissa and Jay but not all bloggers are the same, just as not all journalists are the same.  Larissa, you may not attend any restaurant openings or accept any free gifts but your colleagues certainly do.  That little disclaimer at the bottom of a review that you mention is exactly what is used in the travel section of your newspaper.  Jay, I’m not going to argue that taking a freebie doesn’t impact on someone’s opinion.  But that’s why disclosure of any freebies is key.  I’d also argue being a well known TV personality as well as critic means the experience you have at a restaurant is far removed from that of the general population, whether the meal was a freebie or not.  The only person who can really cast stones in this glass house is Jay’s colleague, London restaurant critic Marina O’Loughlin who has fiercely guarded her anonymity.  

DSC04760
Pani puri at The Rickshaw

I can’t defend the actions of some bloggers.  But I can do what I think is right on my little patch of the internet here.  So on Gourmet Chick the majority of the posts are restaurant reviews, hotel reviews and recipes all of which I pay for and attend anonymously.  Anything which I receive for free is marked as such at the start of post and at the end and posts which I receive payment for are marked as sponsored content.  And even if something is free it doesn’t mean I’m going to say it’s any good.

DSC04757
Shitake and enoki rolls at The Rickshaw

Case in point is The Rickshaw.  It’s hard to judge a restaurant on the basis of a preview night.  But what I can say is that problems with food served at a media and blogger preview makes me worried about what you’d get on a normal day.The menu is pan Asian street food.  It sounds a little confused and it is.  

Pannacotta for dessert at The Rickshaw
Pannacotta for dessert at The Rickshaw

Some dishes like Rickshaw Dining’s take on Indian pani puri impress ($5.50) and the cheap prices are also a plus. But a decent nutty chicken mince curry and buttery roti came served with a green papaya side salad which then turned up accompanying almost every dish. Other dishes really disappointed, like the cabbage rolls ($9.50). The mix of shitake and enoki mushroom, rolled and cooked in wombok leaves suffered from being all the same texture without any strong flavours.  On the basis of the preview, I won’t be rushing back with my own money.     

Gourmet Chick was a guest of The Rickshaw

Essentials
Details: The Rickshaw, 199 Gertrude St, Fitzroy (Ph 03 9419 5930)
Damage: Reasonable. But on this occasion I did not pay. 
5/10

7 comments

  1. I have had people argue about this with me before, because 99% of the time I give positive reviews, however that’s my personality! I’m a positive person and I try to see the positive in everything.

  2. […] post is a result of a couple of posts about disclosure and the blogger scene, both here and here, and the resulting twitter conversation. Of course it relates to my percieved situation, as […]

  3. Great post. For what it’s worth, I really like the way you handle freebies / PR etc – as a reader I find you clear, transparent and honest and I trust that you are giving your honest opinions! 🙂

  4. I absolutely agree with everything you have written. I also like Andi’s comments, I am a naturally happy person and my blog states that I sample everything, and share with readers my “best” food, wine and travel finds. So if a venue, restaurant, wine or product finds its way onto my site it means I genuinely liked it. Otherwise, I won’t write a story. I’m not a critic that describes pluses and minus, I just share what I love.

  5. All the sample dishes by Rickshaw Dining look so pretty and tasty too, especially the pannacotta. Yum! Everyone has a right to write what they want and all reviews are subjective and should be taken with a grain of salt. We are talking about food and taste after all. Peace. 🙂

  6. It’s so much easier for some people to tar us with the same brush. I’ve only been to one opening in the last 3 years and I didn’t cover it. Speaking in such broad terms is sloppy and poor research. Don’t get me started on it. Absolutely agree with you Cara!

  7. Andi – I know that’s a common approach but I’d hate for someone to go somewhere based on my recommendation when I had only talked about the positives and not any negatives.

    Sarah – Thanks very much – ditto!

    Gourmet Getaways – Yes I think this is a common approach – and one a lot of newspapers are using as well.

    Padaek – Peace indeed.

    Lorraine – I thought you might!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *